Insurance
What it would cost to buy a comparable piece at retail within a reasonable time. Usually the highest of the figures.
Hire: personal property appraiser
Reference / before you book an appraiser
Most finds only need identifying. When an insurer, the IRS, a court or an executor will rely on a number, you need a signed report from a qualified appraiser. This page covers when that is, how fees work and how to choose one.
Appraisal brief
Fill one in before your first call
§ 01 Purpose
The same chair can carry three honest values. A good appraiser first asks why you need the report, because the purpose sets the value definition, and the value definition sets the figure.
What it would cost to buy a comparable piece at retail within a reasonable time. Usually the highest of the figures.
Hire: personal property appraiser
The price between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both reasonably informed, neither forced to act. Used for estate returns and dividing inheritances.
Hire: USPAP compliant appraiser
When you claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property, the IRS generally requires a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser.
See: IRS Publication 561
What it is likely to bring in its most suitable market, after selling costs. An auction estimate often answers this without a formal report.
Ask: an auction specialist first
§ 02 Decision path
Four questions, in order. Stop at the first one that settles it.
§ 03 Process
Formats differ between appraisers, but a defensible appraisal follows these six stages.
1
Intended use, intended users and the value type, agreed in writing.
2
Membership in ASA, AAA or ISA, a specialty that fits the piece and current USPAP training.
3
Hourly or flat, with an estimate of hours. Never a percentage of the value.
4
Provenance, receipts, earlier reports and clear photos of marks, labels and damage.
5
Measurements, construction, marks, condition and market research.
6
Value conclusion, method, comparables, limiting conditions and a signed certification.
§ 04 Costs
Rates vary by region, specialty and report type, so ask for the fee basis and an estimate of hours before any work starts.
| Fee basis | Typical use | Ask before you agree |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly | Single items that need research, estates | Estimated hours, and whether research and report writing are billed |
| Flat per item | One or a few pieces, online photo appraisals | Is a signed written report included, or only a verbal opinion? |
| Day rate on site | Households, collections, insurance schedules | Travel costs, number of items covered, delivery date of the report |
| Auction estimate | Selling decisions | It is not an appraisal: the auction house hopes to consign the piece |
| Percentage of value | Red flag | Professional codes and USPAP reject pay that depends on the value conclusion |
§ 05 Credentials
Search the directories of the professional societies, then confirm the appraiser's specialty matches your piece: a furniture specialist is the wrong person for Asian ceramics.
Accredited members in personal property disciplines, with a searchable directory.
Fine and decorative arts appraisers, with a find an appraiser search.
Personal property appraisers, searchable by specialty and location.
The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, published by The Appraisal Foundation.