antiqueappraiser.online Get the app

Reference / before you book an appraiser

When you need a professional appraisal, and what it costs.

Most finds only need identifying. When an insurer, the IRS, a court or an executor will rely on a number, you need a signed report from a qualified appraiser. This page covers when that is, how fees work and how to choose one.

Appraisal brief

Item
Walnut tall case clock
Purpose
Insurance schedule
Value type
Replacement value
Effective
Date of inspection
Bring
Receipts, earlier reports, photos of marks

Fill one in before your first call

§ 01 Purpose

The purpose decides the number.

The same chair can carry three honest values. A good appraiser first asks why you need the report, because the purpose sets the value definition, and the value definition sets the figure.

Replacement value

Insurance

What it would cost to buy a comparable piece at retail within a reasonable time. Usually the highest of the figures.

Hire: personal property appraiser

Fair market value

Estate and probate

The price between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both reasonably informed, neither forced to act. Used for estate returns and dividing inheritances.

Hire: USPAP compliant appraiser

Fair market value

Charitable donation

When you claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property, the IRS generally requires a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser.

See: IRS Publication 561

Marketable cash value

Selling

What it is likely to bring in its most suitable market, after selling costs. An auction estimate often answers this without a formal report.

Ask: an auction specialist first

§ 02 Decision path

Do you need a formal appraisal?

Four questions, in order. Stop at the first one that settles it.

  1. Will an insurer, the IRS, a court or an executor rely on the result?

    YESHire a credentialed appraiser and ask for a written report prepared under USPAP.
    NOGo to question 2.
  2. Could the piece plausibly be worth more than the appraiser's fee?

    YESA paid appraisal can make sense. Go to question 3.
    NO OR NOT SUREPre-check it first: identify it from photos and look at comparable listings before paying anyone.
  3. Do you mainly want to sell it?

    YESAsk two specialist auction houses for an estimate before paying for a report.
    NOGo to question 4.
  4. Is it a group of items, a whole house or a collection?

    YESAsk for an on site day rate and a scope letter that lists every item covered.
    NOA single item appraisal, in person or from detailed photos, is usually enough.

§ 03 Process

How a professional appraisal runs.

Formats differ between appraisers, but a defensible appraisal follows these six stages.

  1. 1

    State the purpose

    Intended use, intended users and the value type, agreed in writing.

  2. 2

    Check credentials

    Membership in ASA, AAA or ISA, a specialty that fits the piece and current USPAP training.

  3. 3

    Agree scope and fee

    Hourly or flat, with an estimate of hours. Never a percentage of the value.

  4. 4

    Prepare

    Provenance, receipts, earlier reports and clear photos of marks, labels and damage.

  5. 5

    Inspection and research

    Measurements, construction, marks, condition and market research.

  6. 6

    Written report

    Value conclusion, method, comparables, limiting conditions and a signed certification.

§ 04 Costs

How appraisers bill, and what to ask.

Rates vary by region, specialty and report type, so ask for the fee basis and an estimate of hours before any work starts.

Fee basisTypical useAsk before you agree
HourlySingle items that need research, estatesEstimated hours, and whether research and report writing are billed
Flat per itemOne or a few pieces, online photo appraisalsIs a signed written report included, or only a verbal opinion?
Day rate on siteHouseholds, collections, insurance schedulesTravel costs, number of items covered, delivery date of the report
Auction estimateSelling decisionsIt is not an appraisal: the auction house hopes to consign the piece
Percentage of valueRed flagProfessional codes and USPAP reject pay that depends on the value conclusion

§ 05 Credentials

Where to find a qualified appraiser.

Search the directories of the professional societies, then confirm the appraiser's specialty matches your piece: a furniture specialist is the wrong person for Asian ceramics.

Society

American Society of Appraisers

Accredited members in personal property disciplines, with a searchable directory.

appraisers.org

Society

Appraisers Association of America

Fine and decorative arts appraisers, with a find an appraiser search.

appraisersassociation.org

Society

International Society of Appraisers

Personal property appraisers, searchable by specialty and location.

isa-appraisers.org

Standard

USPAP

The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, published by The Appraisal Foundation.

appraisalfoundation.org